Back in the day I had a 2004 GTO. It wore AS tires, drove it in everything but snow. Toyo wore extremely fast, the GY Eagle's after 10kmi were noisy as hell, then switched to Mich (can't remember exactly which but they were AS) and they were like night and day the best, even after 30k mi. It was a real slap in the head about wasting time trying to find a cheaper alternative.
If you plan to drive in temps below 45F, MikeD is right on, AS is the way to go!
If I were you, I'd be looking at Mich AS tires.